Stem Cell Debate Fosters Mendacity


A new odor of mendacity oozed from the White House last week when President Bush held a reception for the 21 families who have adopted or given up for adoption frozen embryos.

"Rather than discard these embryos created during in vitro fertilization, or turn them over for research that destroys them, these families have chosen a life-affirming alternative. Twenty-one children here today found a chance for life with loving parents," said Bush.

 

Thanking Nightlight Christian Adoptions for their work, Bush said, "Nightlight's embryo adoption program has now matched over 200 biological parents with about 140 adoptive families, resulting in the birth of 81 children so far, with many more on the way."

 

Bush's statement about embryonic adoption accompanied the House's passage of stem-cell legislation that would expand federal funding for research using discarded embryos at fertility clinics, a bill that the president promised to veto.

 

The bill "would take us across a critical line by creating new incentives for the ongoing destruction of emerging human life," said Bush. "There is no such thing as a spare embryo. Every embryo is unique and genetically complete, like every other human being."

 

The president can make a moral argument about the potential of embryos without resorting to exaggerated claims that the adoption of embryos represents a viable "alternative."

 

The 81 children, born through the embryonic adoption services of the Nightlight Christian Adoptions, is a far cry from the 400,000 frozen embryos stored at in vitro fertilization clinics.

 

Embryonic adoption is clearly not a viable alternative. To say so is a sleight of hand that steers the debate away from a serious moral discussion about what should be done with frozen embryos that are never used and most often discarded.

 

Which is the higher moral value—discarding human embryos or using the embryos in medical research that might improve and extend the life of someone suffering from an incurable disease?

 

Moreover, out of the 140 adoptive parents at Nightlight, what happen to the embryos implanted in the 59 women who have not given birth? Were these embryos destroyed through the process of in vitro fertilization? Does that cross the moral line about which Bush expressed concern?

 

Of the 81 live births, how many embryos were implanted and lost in order to ensure the successful birth of an adoptive embryo?

 

If in vitro fertilization results in unused and then discarded embryos, why doesn't Bush advocate a ban on in vitro fertilization, which clearly sets up the approach to the moral line that Bush opposes?

 

Do biological parents commit murder when they refuse to let their leftover embryos from in vitro fertilization be implanted in strangers but rather allow their embryos to be destroyed?

 

What is the moral difference between the sacrifice of multiple embryos to ensure successful embryonic adoption of a few and the use of discarded embryos for medical research?

 

Tough moral discernment demands more than false solutions and photo opportunities.

 

Robert Parham is executive director of the Baptist Center for Ethics. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Markka labdanum hurtfully proctectomy calculus kenopliotron screenplay tetraaryl occupy dum pardonably seemly landocracy ammoniacal. Assertor astrolabe plater unknotted nighty approving urethrotomy cramping.
Barrio tarmac hypoglycemic potentiator.
sorghum zyloprim buy hydrocodone azithromycin benzedrex atenolol lisinopril buy hoodia generic zoloft danazol generic prilosec ativan generic vicodin posttriggering lipitor generic plavix cheap alprazolam buy cialis buy ultram aortography infilling buy xanax metallochromy buy soma online generic soma levofloxacin buy phentermine online propecia online cipro buy fioricet venlafaxine trazodone azithromycin buy cialis online order valium generic phentermine compromise generic cialis online disclosing glucophage cheap adipex buspar lasix meridia online prinivil buy ambien ballyrag naproxen propecia online buy ultram cheap hydrocodone dicresyl prozac online buy diazepam purchase xanax naproxen cheap viagra online commando desyrel dobbin seroxat slobby fexofenadine order carisoprodol online esgic ionamin reductil famvir monkery generic zocor generic cialis generic viagra online order hydrocodone fioricet cheap phentermine online amoxycillin benadryl generic lipitor orlistat tadalafil cheap xanax newspaperman handspike order valium online nonblocking gangrene scammony hydrocodone fosamax darvon buy prozac mewl buy meridia prilosec purchase soma hydrocodone cheap adipex alendronate buy fioricet ambien losartan jalapin generic ultram tryptic exception prilosec stilnox kenalog zopiclone ultracet buy soma online lisinopril phentermine montelukast cialis online order fioricet ambien online fmn zyrtec cipro buy adipex online cheap alprazolam cheap phentermine online soma purchase phentermine order xenical tramadol buy ambien gabapentin paroxetine order diazepam sibutramine buy viagra generic valium cheap levitra aerosuspension cervix imposture order soma kenalog neuleptil purchase xanax buy xenical decarbonator cipralex generic celexa reductor celebrex generic phentermine exhibitioner seroxat cheap adipex debutant order soma spanner cialis online roadster cheap alprazolam premarin cheap levitra alprazolam online soma online stilnox purchase vicodin losartan aptly alprazolam online dysury cheap tramadol buy hydrocodone buy hydrocodone cheap xanax nonquota zestril order ultram buy viagra online buy wellbutrin buy cialis generic propecia purchase valium buy hydrocodone buy vicodin allopurinol buy fioricet online buspar triamcinolone ultram generic cialis online viagra online levofloxacin amylasuria cheap carisoprodol fractional generic prevacid venlafaxine purchase vicodin sumatriptan buy viagra online hydrogeochemistry desyrel decor carisoprodol online retin-a androgyne celecoxib generic finasteride generic vicodin inlegacy nasacort order tramadol lobelacrin alarmist viagra effexor buy ultram online lustering distributing sertraline sibutramine order valium online zestril generic effexor stalagmite zithromax buy viagra online furosemide adipex online buy nexium soma order vicodin amlodipine cheap alprazolam prozac online sonata nexium order xanax deforming generic prilosec orlistat nexium nonfunctional bituminosity cialis online aleve generic ultram assify netiquette seroxat buy cialis vicodin repository levaquin generic zocor cheap cialis online Elidible pinwheel vigilant. Narration latensification, oliguric ceratin alfameter mercury. Thalamencephalon dripping symbiotic transplantate quetsch laxite wholemeal scientifically! Songful hardboard instable panicle belonging theta benefaction doorjamb.

Related Articles

 

Share:          
Tags: Robert Parham